Imagine you went to the pharmacy and told the pharmacist,
"Give the cheapest medicine you have that comes in 250mg pills."
 |
| Fever's not gone, but...... |
"That doesn't matter....just give me the cheapest one that comes in 250mg pills," you respond. So you grab the cheapest medicine on the shelf that comes in 250mg pills, and you confidently walk out of the store with Viagra, even though you have a fever.
That seems a little ridiculous, but we see this every day in the world of air compressors. Several times per day, we have a customer that asks us for a compressor in a certain horsepower. When you ask for a compressor based on horsepower, what you are doing is very similar to pharmacy situation described above.
Horsepower (hp) is not an accurate way to size an air compressor. Horsepower is a number assigned by a manufacturer to represent how much power the engine or motor can deliver. However, that number can be creatively altered by manufactures to show what they want it to show, and more often than not that is the case. Additionally the hp rating only tells you rating of one component of the package. It doesn't tell you what's going on with the other components.
This creative horsepower labeling is extremely common consumer world. Go to Home Depot and Lowes, and you might see compressors that plug into your wall that say 5hp or 6.5hp.
 |
| If you see this plug, it's 1.5 hp or less |
So any compressor that plugs into your wall at home with a regular plug is 1.5hp or less, no matter what it says on the label.
So what about the 230V compressors that they sell at a big box store or automotive store?
If it says 5 hp or 7.5 hp, then that's probably the actual hp or close to it. If you see some other hp rating than that, like 6.5 hp or 9 hp, then you know some creative labeling has been applied.
You can look at the amps to see the correct horsepower on it.
A 5 hp will be around 21 amps, and a 7.5 hp will be around 35 amps.
It's not just compressors where you'll see this, there have been several class action lawsuits where manufacturers were giving "peak hp" ratings. The horsepower on vacuums, lawnmowers, and cars have all been creatively labeled. There was one which involved air compressors, as well. If you see the words "peak hp," on anything you can completely ignore that horsepower rating - it means absolutely nothing.
It's not just the consumer world either. Horsepower labeling in the industrial world often goes the other way with horsepower. Let's look at some popular industrial brands and their 100 hp compressors. I'm going to link you to the CAGI data sheets, and look at line 11, which is the input kW at full load.
Kaeser CSD-100S: 77.0kW - 417 SCFM at 115 psi
Kaeser CSD-100: 90.6kW - 494 SCFM at 115 psi
Ingersoll-Rand R75I: 89.4 kW - 455 SCFM at 115 psi
Gardner Denver Saver II ST 100: 85.9kW - 450 SCFM at 125 psi
Sullair 7509: 90.3 kW - 444 SCFM at 125 psi
Atlas Copco GA-75: 87.3kW - 424 SCFM at 125 psi
Atlas Copco GA-75+: 88.2kW - 483 SCFM at 125 psi
Input kW is the actual amount of power you use when running fully loaded.
Now let's convert kW to hp. 100 hp is 74.6 kW. However, no motor is 100% efficient. That's physically impossible with today's technology. To to calculate the real hp, we need to multiply the kW by the motor efficiency and then convert to hp. As an example, a 100hp motor and 95% efficiency would need input kW of 78.5kW. The motor efficiency rating is line 7 in the CAGI data sheets.
77kW x .941 = 72.5kW = 97.2 hp
90.6kW x .941 = 85.3kW = 114.4 hp
89.4kW x .954 = 85.3kW = 114.4 hp
85.9kW x .954 = 81.9kW = 109.8 hp
90.3kW x .954 = 86.1 kW = 115.5 hp
87.3kW x .945 = 82.5kW = 110.6 hp
88.2kW x .945 = 83.3kW = 111.7 hp
All of those compressors are "100 hp" compressors. There's really only one that's truly close to 100hp, the Kaeser CSD-100S. Among these compressors you have a 15% variance in the amount of power they consume and nearly 16% variance in the amount of air they can give you.
Another great example of this is the Kaeser AS-25, which is called 25 hp. The new version can give you 120 SCFM at 125 psi. Compare that to the Ingersoll Rand 30 hp UP6-30, which gives you 117 SCFM at 125 psi. The Kaeser "25 hp" gives you more air output than the "30hp" Ingersoll-Rand. Just to check the kW on both: the UP6-30 is 28.7 kW and 92.4% efficiency (35.5 hp), and the AS-25 is 23.3 kW and 91.7% efficiency (28.7 hp).
So the Kaeser "25hp" is closer to 30hp and the Ingersoll Rand "30hp" is really 35 hp. Also, the Kaeser gives you more air with about 7 less hp. This is a great example of how useless the horsepower rating is.
Let's add more confusion to he horsepower ratings - gas engines and electric motors of the same hp won't do the same amount of work. If I were running a compressor pump that normally takes a 5 hp electric motor, I would need about a 10 hp gas engine.
So basically it takes double the amount of hp for a gas or diesel engine to do the same amount of work that an electric motor does. Here is a good explanation of why. The short story is that an electric motor just handles the power given to it by the electrical system and translates that to physical force, but a gas engine actually produces power by its combustion.
About 90% of customers who contact us looking for a compressor ask for a certain horsepower, but as you can see sizing up a compressor based on horsepower is not a good idea. It will get you in the ballpark range, but that's it. Air compressors for home use and small business tend to greatly exaggerate their hp ratings, while air compressors targeted toward larger industrial customers tend to give you more horsepower than what's on the label.
Additionally the horsepower of the motor doesn't tell you how efficient the pump is or anything about any of the other components that may affect the compressor output. There is far more variance in these components from compressor to compressor than there is on the motor, and their impact on compressor output is far greater.
So if you size air compressor by horsepower, you'll be in same position as the person who walked out the pharmacy - you'll know what size pills you have, but you won't know what's in them.
So what is the correct way to size a compressor?
....we'll cover that next week.
Well, that a nice blog post, i was looking for this kind of information. Finally i got answer, i have read many blog post but don’t get the complete answer. I must say i appreciate your work. Thanks man for providing the best content.
ReplyDelete